Toilet flanges are small but essential pieces of hardware that are installed beneath the toilets and are hardly visible to us.
If you have also been experiencing any water leaks, a lousy toilet flange could be a possible reason.
However, buying a new toilet flange is not as easy as it might seem.
Certain factors need to be taken care of, and additionally, there are a lot of choices available, which only make the decision harder.
So, today we will see the top 12 picks for the best toilet flange.
You should possess a minimal knowledge about toilet flanges before you choose one for yourself.
So, here are some points which are most important to consider when you are buying.
While there are a whole lot of different types of toilet flanges available; the most common amongst them are usually four types, which are mostly used by the customers.
They include the following.
Made from PVC, these are unarguably the most common type of toilet flanges installed at homes since they come in quite cheap.
Making them quite good value for the money. Moreover, they are lightweight and rust-resistant.
Copper is quite durable and is also rust-resistant, which is a significant selling point of these types of toilet flanges.
Moreover, copper is good at resisting harmful substances such as viruses and bacteria.
Cast Iron Flange
These are the toilet flanges that come in pricier than the others and are only preferred by the customers if they match the already installed hardware.
Suppose you have the pipes made from cast iron; you would probably prefer cast iron flanges as well even if they cost a bit more.
Aluminum essentially combines the pros of both plastic and metal.
Along with being very durable, just like copper, it is quite lightweight and rust-resistant like plastic as well.
Moreover, it is quite flexible, which makes it further convenient.
When you see the actual toilet flanges, you will come to know that there are specific shapes that the toilet flanges come in, there are four basic shapes which are listed below.
You should shape according to your need and not just what you like.
- Regular models
- Deep seal flanges
- Offset flanges
- Repair types
The thickness of the flange should be chosen according to the thickness of the floor of your bathroom.
If the floor is thicker than usual, there is a chance that the flange will not reach the top of the floor if it is usually thick.
So, choose accordingly, or the flange will become useless.
The diameter should also be selected according to the needs.
The width of the pipe you are going to use determines the diameter of the flange you should be buying.
So, make sure you know the pipe if you are going to slide the flange inside or over the pipe.
Top 12 Toilet Flange Reviews
After going through some of the most famous and heavily used toilet flanges in the market and the models with the top customer reviews.
We have come up with our list of the top 12 picks, which will help you choose the best one.
1. Oatey GIDDS-173390 Flange 4-inch
Oatey GIDDS is a replacement toilet flange made from high-quality PVC, which can be used to replace a cast-iron flange easily.
Even though the product is highly durable and lightweight, the best part about it is that it is extremely easy to install and doesn’t even need any additional tools to get it up and to run.
You don’t even need to tear apart the floor and just install it directly without the need for any help.
- Easy to install
- No need to tear down the floor
- not the most durable
2. Oatey 43405 Set-Rite Toilet Flange
Another great product by the same manufacturer, Oatey. The product comes with the same high performance and easy to use construction; however, the style is different than what we saw previously.
Being a toilet flange extender, this is not the original part and can have installed as the supplementary thing.
After installing this toilet flange extender, you don’t need to worry about any water or gas leaks, as this will take care of everything easily.
The construction is made out of durable plastic, which goes on for years, and it works on all types of flanges.
- Works on all types of toilet flanges
- Water & gas-tight seal
- Only code-approved extender out there
- Needs a primary toilet flange to work
3. Oatey 43501 Toilet Flange
Coming with the same excellence as any other product by Oatey, this toilet flange is also very easy and durable to use.
With the installation process also fairly simple, you could just install the flange all by yourself without the need to call any professional or anything, thus avoiding any extra costs.
The body is built from a durable plastic polymer which is lightweight as well as durable and will likely go on for a long period.
- Made from plastic polymer; durable
- Quick installation
- Built-in cutouts
- Doesn’t quite meet American standards
4. Next by Danco 10672X HydroSeat Toilet Flange
If you have a leaky toilet and you need a quick solution for it without being sure what kind of toilet you own, this toilet flange could be the perfect choice for you.
With its ability to fit any standard type of toilet, it is incredibly effective at stopping any leakages whatsoever and makes sure the seal is perfect.
Coming with an affordable price tag, it is quite easy to install and made from durable material.
- Sturdy build
- Easy to install
- Fits most toilets
- Self-centering gasket
- Needs wax rings
- Considered only as a repair
5. Pasco 21013 Toilet Flange
Coming in a ring shape, this toilet flange by Lasco is very durable since the construction is done through metal.
The flange can be very easy to install remedy if you need to repair the existing flange of your toilet or if you have been experiencing any leaks.
The model will fit most standard toilets and features a solid ring.
- Solid ring
- Durable, made from metal
- Fits most toilets
- Simple design
- Tricky to install
- Poor customer support
6. Universal Drain 950P Toilet Flange
This is another excellent 4” toilet flange option if you are looking for something affordable, which is durable and made from plastic.
Being manufactured inside the US, the product meets the durability standards and makes sure it goes on for a long period.
Moreover, it is easy to install and performs flawlessly!
- Easy to install
- Prevents all leakages
- Doesn’t fit most of the toilets
7. Sioux Mfg 886-411 Close Flange Kit
Sioux chief kit is a great product that can be used as a kit when the toilet you have installed in your time starts leaking or goes bad.
The Sioux mfg is a guaranteed performer and will never let you down in taking out any kind of leakages in your toilets.
The ring of this can be stacked quickly needed, and it comes with a durable build
- Rings can be stacked
- Raise the original flanges just fine
- Supplementary product
8. Flexon Toilet Flange
Featuring a very useful spacer system, which is nothing but a fancy name for the toilet flange being quite flexible in its elevation, this product by Coflex comes with a great quality that can be installed for repair purposes or even as a new installment.
The flange can be installed if you have any from PVC, Cast-iron, or lead pipes and will be very effective at stopping any kind of leaks found.
- Can be installed as repair or new
- A spacer system is great
- No wax needed
- Tight seal made
- Durable construction
- Some claims about not fitting the pipe
- Design is not the best
9. Genova Products 75158S Closet Flange
Featuring a stainless-steel build, the quality of the product, and the durability you get with this flange is truly amazing.
The ring is rust-free and strong, which will easily last you for years, stopping any kind of leaks your toilet has been experiencing.
The diameter it has is 4,” and it is extremely easy to install, without the need for any additional tools.
- Easy to install
- Makes air-tight seal
- Durable quality
- Rotating ring
- Can not be used in new toilet flanges
10. Plumbest C54402 PVC Offset Closet Flange
This is one of the best quality products you will ever come across while going over the most durable toilet flanges.
Also, if you are very concerned about the ring going bad, this is seriously the best choice.
Not only the ring doesn’t deteriorate, but it comes with 360-degree rotation, which makes things quite convenient.
Lastly, it angles well in installation and is heavy-duty.
- Heavy duty
- The ring rotates 360 degrees
- Angles good
- The inside design could be better
11. Edgeban Toilet Self Leveling Toilet Flange
This is one of the lesser-known toilet flanges. However, the performance is just like any other top-quality toilet flanges.
Having an affordable price tag, this product provides quite a good value for the money you pay and being probably the best product for self-leveling bathrooms.
The toilet flange comes in a ring shape and helps you protect toilet flange self-leveling underlayment.
- Best for self-leveling bathrooms
- Installs in seconds
- Most suitable for underlayment jobs
- Some customers claimed it’s not big enough
12. Culwell A43 Floor Protecting Flange
Another product for protecting the floor by Culwell.
Along with providing a very tight seal leaving no room for any leaks, there are guidance points provided as well to make the alignment easier.
Moreover, the product is quite strong and features the latest technology patented design, which is very effective.
- Patented effective design
- Provides tight seals
- Flat surface design
- Can be used with any water barrier membrane
- Slightly expensive
Frequently Asked Questions
When you are a beginner, there are certain points that you often wonder about.
Don’t worry as you are not alone as a lot of people face those confusions. Let’s see some of those.
Is the toilet flange supposed to be flush with the floor?
Yes, the toilet flange strictly needs to be on the surface, with its lowest point being on the ground level.
For example, if you have tiles installed on the bathroom floor, the flange needs to be on top of tiles as well.
Does the toilet flange go inside the pipe?
Yes, it does. If you own an inside closet flange, it will be glued inside of the pipe for effective usage or will expand inside the pipe.
Can a toilet flange be too high?
No, the toilet flange can not be too high when installed. If it is, then the seal might not be tight enough, or the toilet may not be fixed tightly onto the floor.
Both leakage and lose toilet could result in floor breakage.
Should I caulk around the toilet flange?
Even though it is not necessary, but it can be beneficial as it can help securely join the toilet to the ground, thus preventing any leaks better than before.
Can you install a toilet without a flange?
Yes, you theoretically can install a toilet without a flange; however, it is certainly not recommended.
You will have to attach the toilet directly to the ground, which will not prevent leaks very nicely or rocking of the toilet, eventually resulting in floor damage.
As we saw, there are some amazing quality products when it comes to toilet flanges and their extenders.
While you cannot deny their importance, you should always choose the products which meet your needs effectively as not all people need the same thing.
So, make sure you go through the buying guide first and then choose according to your personal preferences.